
At One with the Mountains - An interview with Nick Gardner
Issue 6: Nick Gardner and his wife Janet were living an idyllic life on a croft…

A Munro of 1,007 metres, number 126 of the 282.
Photograph by Nick Bramhall (CC BY-SA 2.0)
An Sgarsoch is one of the remote ones.
It stands on the border of Aberdeenshire and Perth and Kinross, in the hills between Glen Tromie and Glen Tilt, with its twin Carn an Fhidhleir about three kilometres to the west.
It has a good story, too. ScotWays records a local tradition, noted in the 1950s, that an early cattle tryst was held on the summit.
Atholl Estates, which calls the neighbouring hill Carn Ealar, looks after ground here. The nearest roof is the estate's Tarf Hotel: a bothy, whatever the name says, about five kilometres away in a straight line.
West wind to 13 mph, gusting 26
Rain, about 2 mm
Light from 7.49am to 6.11pm, ten hours
A weather model's forecast for the height of the summit, not a report from the hill. Read the mountain forecast the evening before: Cairngorms National Park and Monadhliath forecast, Southeastern Highlands forecast, An Sgarsoch, Southern Cairngorms avalanche forecast, Northern Cairngorms avalanche forecast.
Choose the day you mean to climb.Near or far: the light you will have, and what the summit is likely to be doing.

Photographs by Nick Bramhall (CC BY-SA 2.0)

At the Geldie Burn there is no longer any bridge.ScotWays, of the right of way from the Linn of Dee to Blair Atholl
Under snow and ice this is a different day, with short light and the risk of avalanche. It needs an ice axe, crampons, winter boots and the skill to use them.
The summit is optional. Turning back is the right decision whenever the cloud, the wind or the light say so.
How to call for help in the hills · Safety and skills for the hills · ThinkWINTER
Nobody has written from An Sgarsoch yet. If you were up, yours would be the first.
Were you up? Three words is enough.A free account, a word for the weather and a line if you like.

Issue 6: Nick Gardner and his wife Janet were living an idyllic life on a croft…

Issue 13: Scotland's mountains can reveal their challenges as quickly as their…

Issue 5: Here are six of my favourite bothies, all great locations for a…
For the route itself, take the map and read these.
Next along: Carn an Fhidhleir, Carn a' Chlamain, Beinn Bhrotain, Beinn Dearg. Checked on 10 October 2026. The facts on this page are Atholl Estates', ScotWays', the Mountain Bothies Association's and the National Trust for Scotland's; the forecasts are the Mountain Weather Information Service's, the Met Office's and the Scottish Avalanche Information Service's. Height and position from The Database of British and Irish Hills, v18.3, adapted, CC BY 4.0. This page is not a route description and does not replace a map.