Bonn Pizza: An Interview with Grant Hutchison.

InterviewHidden Scotland

Photograph · Bonn Pizza

Bonn Pizza is a family-run, New York-style pizzeria in Anstruther, in the East Neuk of Fife, where the sourdough bases are made with a local bakery and fermented for 48 hours. Grant and Jaye Hutchison opened it after five years of running Aeble, Scotland’s first dedicated cider bar and shop.

In this interview Grant talks about a love of New York pizza that goes back to their wedding reception, a restaurant where families never feel out of place, a drawing competition that could win a free pizza, and a favourite local secret above Anstruther harbour.

Grant Hutchison, smiling, carries a stack of pizza boxes out of the red door at Bonn Pizza.
Bonn Pizza
The lit sign outside Bonn Pizza, a square of cream and red checks that reads East Neuk Pizza.
Bonn Pizza

For anyone discovering it for the first time, what is Bonn Pizza?

Bonn Pizza is our version of a neighbourhood pizzeria you might find more commonly in New York City. We have tried to create a welcoming place to enjoy great food and drinks with friends, family and beyond. We strive to use the best local ingredients we can find by working with a local bakery for our sourdough pizza base, keeping it as authentic as we can and obviously as tasty as possible!

A bottle of cider, a glass and a plate of olives on a red-tiled table by the window at Bonn Pizza.
Bonn Pizza
A glass of sparkling wine and a bowl of olives on a red-tiled table, a plant beside them.
Bonn Pizza

You and Jaye ran Aeble, Scotland’s first dedicated cider bar and shop, for five years. What made pizza feel like the right next chapter?

I think we realised after five years that cider isn’t for everyone and although we had some local support it became pretty clear that Anstruther maybe just didn’t need a cider bar. We’re really proud of what we achieved with it and our contribution to the wider world of cider by opening Aeble but we have noticed right away with Bonn that pizza is far more universal and something everyone can enjoy. Aeble wasn’t really somewhere locals would come with kids and family and being parents of young kids ourselves that was something we knew Bonn had to try and achieve and pizza felt like it ticked all those boxes.

A New York-style pizza and a pint of lager on a wooden table in low sunlight.
Bonn Pizza
A hand taking a slice from a cheese and tomato pizza on a red-rimmed plate.
Bonn Pizza

What was the thinking behind the pizza itself — the dough, the style, the toppings?

We both love New York and the pizza culture there. It’s where we got married and we had NY pizza at our wedding reception so it’s something we’re passionate about. It’s now pretty easy to get Neapolitan style pizza most places so we felt it was important to do something different. We worked with the local bakery, Barnetts to create our own sourdough starter. The dough is fermented for 48 hours and delivered fresh to the restaurant every day so we’re never using frozen dough and the main ingredient is as fresh as it can be. The toppings are fairly classic and we’ve kept the menu pretty small so you’re not bombarded with loads of topping choices which is a real bugbear of mine on a lot of menus.

Friends sharing two pizzas at a wooden table, seen from above, with glasses of water and a bottle of beer.
Bonn Pizza

How do you want people to feel when they come in?

Ideally we want people to feel welcome, happy and comfortable. We want to make sure that families can eat there and not feel like it’s only a once in a while treat in terms of price too. I think pizza encourages sharing and is a great food to have conversations over and again creates that feeling of togetherness and community. We did our best with the renovations to make it feel cosy and intimate but at the same time if you spill a drink or make a mess then you don’t feel self conscious about it. Pizza is meant to be messy and eaten with your hands so it’s a very levelling cuisine!

Drawing on a sheet of paper at the table at Bonn Pizza, a pot of coloured pencils and an ice cream beside it.
Bonn Pizza

Bonn Pizza feels genuinely family-friendly, the kids menu and the drawing competition especially. How important is that to you?

It’s absolutely vital. There are a lot of great restaurants in the East Neuk but family friendly places are harder to come by so we wanted to make sure that kids and parents didn’t feel out of place. Whenever we go places and realise we’ve forgotten a drawing pad or something for the kids it’s so frustrating and you either resort to a phone or playing a version of I spy throughout the whole meal which isn’t ideal. We worked with the wonderful ilka studio on the design and branding and they came up with the idea of a drawing competition. A menu that kids can draw on isn’t a new thing but when they know there’s a possibility of free pizza at the end of it then they might just take a little longer to finish their piece of art!

A slice of pepperoni pizza held out on a paper plate.
Bonn Pizza
A counter along the window at Bonn Pizza, with tall stools and a plant on the sill.
Bonn Pizza

What’s next for Bonn Pizza?

We’re already considering the next step for Bonn. We’re considering a truck or potentially a slice only, takeaway option which is more like the NYC style of pizza place. We all live here in the East Neuk so we’re not looking to expand beyond here and our relationship with Barnetts means we probably couldn’t anyway so increasing our presence in the area here is something we’re keen to do and makes most sense for us. With Aeble we also did a lot of collaborations with local businesses so that’s something we’re keen to add to Bonn. Pizza is such an adaptable meal that I think we could work with a lot of people and still make something great.

A sharing board of sourdough, burrata, cured ham, almonds and olives on a red-tiled table, a bottle of red wine behind.
Bonn Pizza
White anchovies laid in olive oil with herbs on a plate, on red tiles.
Bonn Pizza

East Neuk has such a strong food and drink community. Who else do you admire around here?

We have always been huge fans of Baern. Hazel and Giacomo have created something very unique and special and the food and atmosphere there is exceptional without being stuffy and too ‘fine dining’. The supper clubs and evening meals they run are such great nights and their commitment to local, seasonal produce is something I have so much respect for and love tasting. I’m also very excited to have Cormo Bakery open here too. Matt and Julianna used to run Hobz in Edinburgh and we did occasional collabs with them. I feel very lucky that they’ve chosen to open here and bring some excellent bakes to the East Neuk. Specifically, the panettone and the cookies they make are delicious.

Grant Hutchison carries pizza boxes along the harbour wall at Anstruther, boats moored behind.
Bonn Pizza

Favourite spot to visit nearby in the East Neuk?

One place that is excellent and very underrated is The Rockies restaurant at Anstruther Golf Club. I’m almost hesitant to let people know about it because it still feels like a secret for locals but the food is brilliant and affordable and the views from the clubhouse room are incredible. It offers an alternative view to most seaside eateries here as it looks back over to Anstruther harbour and if you look in the other direction it’s basically sea. The burger is my go to but any of the seafood options are great too as they use local suppliers who offer the freshest ingredients.

A pepperoni pizza in its open box on the harbour wall, the sea behind.
Bonn Pizza
A silver cup of soft-serve ice cream and a cookie on a plate printed with the Bonn name.
Bonn Pizza

Bonn Pizza, 28b Shore Street, Anstruther KY10 3AQ.

Recommend to a friend

Places in this article.

Every place in the article, for you to visit
Hidden Scotland, Issue ThirteenOut now
Hidden Scotland, in print

Twice a year, to your door.

One hundred and sixty pages of Scotland, every photograph commissioned, every word written by someone who went. Members get both issues posted and everything on screen.

The Daily for 20 November, from Scotland with love. A line of seaweed marks the tide along a sandy beach backed by dune grass and a hillside of pine and golden larch.

The Daily

Arrives at 5am every day.

A free morning email to see what’s on this week, catch up on what’s happening in Scotland and find somewhere new to go.

Something to do · An advertA woman beams as she holds up the pair of entwined iron hearts she and her partner have forged.Gretna Green, Dumfries and Galloway

Forge two hearts at Gretna Green.

A private hour and a half for two at the working forge, making a pair of entwined hearts with the blacksmith. For an a special occasion, a romantic escape or simply something memorable to do together.